In my previous post , I have tabulated and compared three pineapple tart recipes by standardising their butter content to 100g in order to have a better understanding their differences. Using my homemade pineapple jam, I have baked the tarts and let's see the result...
Here are the interesting characteristics, pros and cons of the three recipes used:
One from Mandy of Fresh from the Oven
This recipe uses creaming method to cream butter and egg yolk before mixing in the dry ingredients.
Pros - The pastry dough is easy to handle even at room temperature.
Cons - The baked tarts are quite fragile and require careful handling when stacking them into the cookie jars. As shown in Mandy's post, hers were the enclosed ones and I reckon the enclosed ones might be tougher to handle than the open-faced ones.
Two from Alvina of Alvina's Baking Journey
This recipe uses rubbing-in method and contains milk powder to create a nice melt-in-the mouth effect.
Pros - True enough that the pastry of these tarts does melt-in-the-mouth with a little extra milky taste. Good that this recipe can be used to make both enclosed and open-faced kind of pineapple tarts.
Cons - Pastry dough is very soft and need to be chilled before shaping and rolling.
Three from Sugahmommy of A Spoonful of Sugah
This recipe uses rubbing-in method and contains whole egg and the least amount of sugar.
Pros - The tarts are sturdy and stacking them into cookie jar is never a problem. As described, these tarts are indeed slightly firmer with a biscuit-like texture.
Cons - Pastry dough is very soft too and need to be chilled before shaping and rolling.
Now which recipe do you think is the best...
![]() |
More pineapple tarts made with my homemade pineapple jam |
![]() |
The Fresh from the Oven recipe uses creaming method and the other two use rubbing-in method. |
![]() |
Shaping the open-face tarts with different pastry moulds... |
![]() |
... this helps to differentiate the different recipes used. |
![]() |
The answer is here! |
![]() |
Thumb up from my little boy! |
(with my notes and modification in blue)
Ingredients:

All of the above standardised recipes do not contain any vanilla extract or iced water for fair comparison
My egg wash: 1 egg yolk plus 2 tbsp of milk
Methods
Recipe One, Fresh from the oven
Sieve all purpose flour, corn flour, salt and icing sugar into a medium bowl. Beat butter in a mixer until it turns light in color and fluffy. Add in egg yolk until well combined. Slowly beat in the flour mixture until just combined.
Although the dough is workable at this stage, I have standardised all recipes and chilled the dough for at least 30 mins before proceeding the assembly.
To assemble, roll pineapple filling into small individual rounds. Turn dough out and roll into small rounds. Flatten the rounds and use it to cover the prepared filling.
Note: I rolled the dough into 0.5 cm thickness and cut them into shapes into my mould. I placed small and rolled teaspoonful of pineapple jam in the center of each pastry and decorated the edge with a pincher.
Brush the unbaked rolls with egg wash.
Bake in a preheated oven at 350F/180ºC for 10 to 15 mins or till lightly brown.
Recipe Two, Alvina's Baking Journey
Whisk top flour, milk powder, icing sugar together until very mix well.
Rub in the cold butter cubes with your finger tips until the mixture resembles breadcrumb. Add egg yolk to the flour and butter mixture and gently mix with a spatula until the dough comes together.
Knead very briefly , wrap in clingwrap and chill for 15 to 30 mins.
Preheat oven 200ºC. Portion pastry dough into 8 to 9 g each , flatten dough and wrap in 1 tsp of pineapple paste.
Note: I rolled the dough into 0.5 cm thickness and cut them into shapes into my mould. Then, I placed small and rolled teaspoonful of pineapple jam in the center of each pastry
Brush the pastry ball with egg and bake for 13 to 16 mins.
Recipe Three, A Spoonful of Sugah
Sift flours and icing sugar together, twice. Cut butter into small pieces and run into sifted flour. After it is completely rubbed in, add egg and then slowly add in the cold water (only if needed and I didn't do that) to get a nice and fairly firm dough.
Wrap each portion in plastic wrap and chill for 30 mins. Roll out into 0.5 cm thickness between 2 sheets of plastic and then chill again for another 15 mins. (I skipped this chilling step)
Meanwhile, roll jam into small balls for easy filling.
Take out dough and cut using a pineapple tart mould. Fill with jam. If dough is too soft to work with, flour your hands, the work table and rolling pin, making sure not to add too much flour to the dough or it will become tough. If necessary, flour the tart cutter before cutting each tart, so that the tart removes easily with all its patterns/grooves intact.
Arrange tarts on tray lined with baking paper. Chill in fridge for about 10 mins (I skipped this last chilling step), then bake at 140ºC for about 30 mins. When ready, leave to cool and store.
----
For all three recipes, I have baked all tarts at 160ºC fan forced for 13 mins
----
We are very happy with all the tarts made with the above recipes but there is always a winner in respective with all comparisons and the winner is Recipe One, Fresh from the oven
Although the fresh from the oven's tarts are quite fragile and difficult to handle, they are the tastiest of all. In fact, this recipe contains the most amount of icing sugar than the other two. Interestingly, even with more flours content and without the milk powder, these simple tarts are able to melt into our mouth and even melt better than the ones made with the other two recipes.
With all these baking, I also learned that whole eggs does firm up the final texture of pastry creating a nice biscuit-y texture. And, if you are the person who prefer the biscuit-y kind of pineapple tart, Recipe Three, A Spoonful of Sugah would be the perfect recipe for you.
Remember my last year post when I baked my pineapple tarts using the recipe by The Little Teochew? I really love the tarts made with this recipe and did re-visited The Little Teochew recipe a few times after this post. Now, I begin to ask myself... which is better? Fresh from the oven or The Little Teochew?
Honestly, I think both are equally good! Why? I guess this may be the answer to my question...
When I compared both recipes by standardising their butter content to 100g, I found out that they are actually quite the same! Their amount of flour + cornfour, icing sugar and egg yolk are almost the same. The main difference is their mixing method which require an extra 20g of flour to firm up the dough if the butter is creamed at room temperature.

When I compared both recipes by standardising their butter content to 100g, I found out that they are actually quite the same! Their amount of flour + cornfour, icing sugar and egg yolk are almost the same. The main difference is their mixing method which require an extra 20g of flour to firm up the dough if the butter is creamed at room temperature.
Another thing that I have noticed is that The Little Teochew has used 8g more cornflour than Fresh from the oven which makes the pastry more melt-y with a lesser gluten content. When I re-visited The Little Teochew recipe, a curious me had replaced all-purpose flour with cake flour and the outcome is actually quite disastrous! The tarts made with cake flour are extremely fragile to handle and so I would like to conclude that these two recipes have reached their maximum point of their melt-in-mouth composition.
Last and most importantly, I learned not to reduce the amount of icing sugar in any these recipes further. Without adequate amount of sweetness, these pineapple tarts wouldn't be tasty at all.
Depending on individual tastes
and preferences, the best pineapple tart or even other bakes can be
very subjective. I realized that some of my relatives (being Asians) don't like the milky smell of butter at all and prefer their tarts made with margarine. Now, I wondering if any
of these recipes would work well with margarine...
With all these pineapple tarts baking, I'm asking myself... Have I find the pineapple tart recipe? I think so... I have discovered a lot more pineapple tart recipes recently. Some are simply the enclosed kind. Some are the nastar kind. Some are the Taiwan-style kind... In particular, I would like to try these two recipes from Sonia, Nasi Lemak Lover and Angel from Cook.Bake.Love before Chinese New Year next year. If time permits, I would love to try baking a lot more pineapple tarts recipes any time sooner...
Happy Baking
Please support me and like me at Facebook...
With all these pineapple tarts baking, I'm asking myself... Have I find the pineapple tart recipe? I think so... I have discovered a lot more pineapple tart recipes recently. Some are simply the enclosed kind. Some are the nastar kind. Some are the Taiwan-style kind... In particular, I would like to try these two recipes from Sonia, Nasi Lemak Lover and Angel from Cook.Bake.Love before Chinese New Year next year. If time permits, I would love to try baking a lot more pineapple tarts recipes any time sooner...
Happy Baking
Last but not the least, I would like to wish everyone a...


Wow, I am so impressed by your efforts with these tarts! They look amaaaazing!!!
ReplyDeleteI love that you tried all the three and analyses each recipe very well. I will try your winner select, if a little one approves then nothing can beat it.
ReplyDeleteThumbs up for the effort , Zoe!
ReplyDeleteI didnt find my tarts made using recipe 1 fragile though. I had no problems stacking them into tupper ware containers. Maybe because I made them into closed tarts rather than open ones, and I mistakenly baked them longer for 20 to 25 min on the middle tray for my 1st batch, when they should have been baked for 10 to 15 min in the upper tray, (which i did for my 2nd batch). But surprisingly that didnt affect the quality at all, both batches tasted almost the same!
Just curious, why didn't u experiment with wendy's tart recipe? Is it because she used cream cheese which is not used by the others, so you can't make a side-by-side comparison?
Hi B,
DeleteNice to have you analyze lots of pineapple tarts baking with me. We sure love our pineapple tarts... LOL!
You are right that yours are the enclosed ones and so they are much more easier to handle. I baked my open-faced ones for just 13 mins and I reckon our baking times vary due to their difference in sizes and our ovens. I reckon that baking time is critical for open-faced pineapple tart baking as my oven is fan forced which can be over-bake food easily with its high heat and so 13 mins is the optimal timing for me.
Yes that I did tried Wendy's recipe (http://bakeforhappykids.blogspot.com.au/2012/01/getting-ready-for-chinese-new-year.html). Her recipe is good but I still prefer Little Teochew and Mandy's recipe. I'm surprised too that either cream cheese or milk powder can't enhance the melt-y taste of these tarts further. Next, I'm curious to try Sonia's and Cook.Bake.Love's recipes. These two recipes especially Sonia's one are very well-reviewed but all I need now is to find time and pineapples to bake more tarts again...
Cheers!
Zoe
I am glad I only tried one recipe and it turned out to be the best. I have kiv'ed Wendy's pineapple tart recipe but I chose the recipe from SSB (taken from Fresh from the Oven) over hers bcos I personally dun like to play with sticky dough and I din happen to have cream cheese in my fridge. After hearing what you said, I can just stick to that recipe in the future.
DeleteReally thanks for the detailed analysis. I am a hoarder of baking recipes but I dun have the patience to do a detailed analysis like what you did. I depend mostly on the reviews by others and by how much I trust the blogger. Some bloggers tend to over exaggerate while some are not detailed in their steps. :)
Hi Miss B,
DeleteI believe that whether a food is delicious or not can very subjective. The level of acceptance of certain ideal taste or texture can depend very much on individual tastes and preferences and all I can do is to describe my personal opinions as much as possible. Certainly, I hope not to exaggerate or missing out any details... If it is good to me, I would say that it is good... Otherwise, I wouldn't.
Nice to know that we have great passion with our food and love to hear more of your opinions.
Zoe
Oooo I like your heart shaped pineapple tarts! :)
ReplyDeleteWould be really difficult to say which ones are the best.. I always prefer less butter if it's possible
ReplyDeletetarts look wonderful
ReplyDeleteThese are just gorgeous! I love how sunny they look---like bright sunshine (makes me wistful for warmer days) =)
ReplyDeleteThese not only sound delicious but look adorable!!
ReplyDeleteHi Zoe,
ReplyDeleteI have linked back my pineapple tart post to Little Thumbs Up and Bake for Happy Kids. I do not know what I should do next......
Here is my post pineapple tart, do let me know if this is in order or should I email the link to you. Thank you!
http://melspantrykitchen.blogspot.com/2013/02/pineapple-rolls.html
Hi Mel,
DeleteNo worries! I have already submitted the link for you. If you wish to participate our future events like our bake-along or Cook like a Star events. You may wish to know that all you need next is to click an icon with "Add your link" with the little frog face and submit your details accordingly.
If you are interested to blog hop in the future, I can help you step by step so that you can have all our links at your blog too. Cheers!
Zoe
I think recipe wise, some prefer the more crumbly type and some the crispier type, so I find that different recipes simply work for different people. Thanks for the detailed analysis, now I can pick the one I prefer :)
ReplyDeleteThats a great effort Zoe... And the tarts look simply wonderful
ReplyDeleteThese look so yummy!
ReplyDeleteI'm impressed by your effort in trying all those recipes. I hope it was worth it to try to find the perfect recipe for you. =)
Hi Zoe your tarts look so adorable and mouthwatering. Luvd it.
ReplyDeleteYes, fresh the oven looks the best to me too, and I hadn't even tasted those delicious-looking pineapple tarts. The fresh from the oven ones look nice and golden-brown, the crust looks really good...and homemade jam must make them even better.
ReplyDeleteWow, experiment completed! Zoe, your tarts are lovely and I will bookmark your recipe for CNY 2014!
ReplyDeleteSo cute and yum!
ReplyDeletewww.rsrue.blogspot.com
Such cute little tarts!
ReplyDeleteperfect and delicious.
ReplyDeleteZoe , great comparison chart ! So , the search for the ultimate pineapple tart is not over yet ? lol Your tarts are so pretty and I'm sure tastes really delicious ! I'll try this Taiwanese pineapple tart recipe that I've found in one of the newspaper here :D I'll use Sonia's pineapple filling . Will post it sometime next week as I haven't bought fresh pineapple yet :P
ReplyDeleteHi Zoe,
ReplyDeleteThanks for sharing ur experiment and the mention. i like all ur pineapple tarts especially the sun flower, it is very special.
I tried Sonia's recipe this year. The texture of pastry is crumbly (sandy) type whereas my aunt's recipe the pastry is firm yet tender. Taste wise both are well balanced and I reckon my aunt's one is more buttery and milky as the butter to flour ratio is higher and the recipe uses milk powder.
I hope you can give both recipes a try next year and I look forward to reading ur analysis. :)
Thanks Angel for sharing your experience with me. Definitely would try both yours and Sonia's recipes.
DeleteHi Zoe! Happy Lunar New Year! Gong XI Fai Cai!
ReplyDeleteYou are amazing!!! Trying out the different recipes, tabulate the ingredients and analyse the results! This reminds me of my University thesis! :P
Anyway, well done! You have my respect!
Hi Alvin,
DeleteI do feel like writing a thesis analyzing these tarts. Maybe this is what I always do at work... that's why :D
Zoe
You are such an Angel giving those informations. Pineapple tarts are my favourite. So far I have not make it but with your full informations, I believe I will make it in the future. Thanks a lot. Happy Lunar New Year to you and family.
ReplyDeleteBeautiful and delicious!
ReplyDeleteGreat the second time around!
ReplyDeleteTruly gorgeous! LOVE your molds and I love that you found a winner!!!
ReplyDeletePS...thanks for reminding me to update my Twitter profile :) You're a gem!!!
No worries, Lizzy!
DeleteThanks for doing all the testing, so I don't have to. Although I actually like testing like this! Loved both of these posts - thanks so much.
ReplyDeleteWow Zoe, you sure are very determine by studying all the recipes...thank you for the work...I yet have to try to make this tarts as they are very popular here.
ReplyDeleteHappy and Prosperous Chinese New Year!
Hello Zoe! Thank you for your kind comment and for following my blog. It is much appreciated!
ReplyDeleteI always eat fresh pineapple. I rarely ever bake with it. I have vintage pineapple salad I posted on my blog last summer but I am not sure you would be interested in it! But I can link it up with you would like!
Hi Stacy,
DeleteSorry that I can't include your pineapple salad post as I have set one of the conditions of this event to accept any pineapple related posts that is posted within Jan to Feb 2013.
If you are cooking or baking anything with Tomatoes early next month, I would appreciate if you can link with my blogging friend, Doreen. Otherwise, we are cooking Delia Smith for the whole month of March 2013... Wanna join in the fun?
Zoe
They are so pretty!! Like little sun flowers <3
ReplyDeleteAll tarts look so good, Zoe! But I appreciate that you took the time to test all three recipes! Thumbs up to you!
ReplyDeleteComparison posts are some of my favorite.
ReplyDeleteHi Zoe! Happy Chinese New Year and happy Valentine's Day! I love your heart-shape pineapple tarts, really adorable! I've never played around with the different pineapple tarts recipes, as the first one I tried was already a success for me (taken from Fresh from the Oven). I did experimented with different types of butter and found that Elle & Vire makes the most buttery tarts but SCS butter gave the tarts a milky buttery taste.
ReplyDeleteHi Jasline,
DeleteYes... I remember your post showing the difference with different butter used. Totally agree with you that the quality of butter makes a lot of taste differences. My personal favourite is The Danish butter particularly, Lurpak. I love the smell of its creamy milky texture :D
Zoe
Oooh Lurpak's really expensive, my heart breaks whenever I bought a piece to bake haha! I actually wanted to participate in the Little Thumbs Up, thought the deadline was end of February, but realized the link was already closed... oh well... hopefully will be able to participate in the upcoming Tomatoes one!
DeleteWouw Wouw Wouw you absolutely an excellent pineapple tarts fans .... I should try this recipe next year :) Here I would like to wish you and your family a prosperous & fruitful water snake year :) Huat arh !!!
ReplyDeleteWas looking at your pineapple tarts post... what a delightful blog you have...
ReplyDeleteI have just baked Sonia's version of pineapple tarts and they were delicious! I hope I have time to post it before this event close.
ReplyDeleteMy daughter would go nuts over these...she loves all things pineapple.
ReplyDeleteProblem is she's the only 1 in our house that does so I don't use it alot.
Think ill treat her with these they look lovely! :)
Wow Zoe - amazing detail and beautifully presented. I can't believe that you can still enjoy these tarts after making so many of them :-)
ReplyDeleteWow! What an interesting post & very lovely tarts . My fussy boss does not like the crumble pineapple tarts. But I on the other hand love those melt in the mouth pineapple tarts. So I think you've found the perfect pastry dough - biscuit-like texture. Thanks for posting these recipes will try it out for but Mr. fussy! LOL BTW I'll be posting a pineapple recipe that I love to share . Hopefully I won't forget to post it before the deadline! LOL
ReplyDeleteHi Kit,
DeleteNo worries! Please let me know if you need to bring forward the deadline :D
Zoe
Hi Zoe, Thanks a lot of adding my post to Little Thunmbs Up event . I was few hours late to submit my pineapple post & I don't want to bother you about it. But I promise that I won't be late for TOMATO event! In fact I've already done it ! hehehehe
DeleteLooks good la! I must try this recipe next year.
ReplyDeleteDo you find that pineapple tart don't keep fresh for long as the jam seems to soften the biscuits base after a few days? My mother-in-law always keep hers in the fridge to keep fresh. I prefer the melt in the mouth base and sugar is important to balance the sourness from the pineapple. Great post Zoe and happy CNY to you!
ReplyDeleteHi Veronica,
DeleteIf your pineapple jam is well cooked with not much water content, the tart pastry should be soften at all. I prefer to store my tarts in room temperature for its nice and soft buttery texture. They can harden when they are stored at room temperature. I reckon in this case, the jam is the critical factor :D
Zoe
Some pineapple tarts recipe! U're such a temptress!!
ReplyDeleteHi Zoe,
ReplyDeleteGreat analysis of the different pineapple tarts! You did a swell job. I love pineapple tarts and have not made any in years!
these are gorgeous!! i'd love to be munching on some of these now!
ReplyDeleteZoe you made such lovely little treats and the post is so thorough and analytical. My God you worked so hard on this, but it is definitely worth it!
ReplyDeleteGood morning, Zoe, love your pineapple tarts. I made something that used fresh pineapple juice on Valentine's Day and realised that I can submit it to your Little Thumbs Up but I've promised myself will only start "working" again on Tue(19th Feb), is it too late for the submission? Is this running for the entire month of Feb? I use tomatoes for like 4-5 times a week in my daily cooking, see whether I have something interesting to share later as well. Oh, before I forgot, where can I get those cookies press in Australia? Have a nice weekend!
ReplyDeleteHi Jessie,
DeleteNo worries at all. Please let me know if you need me to bring forward the closing date.
Please join us at our tomato event. Doreen will be happy *wink*
To answer your question, I actually bought my tart moulds from Poon Huat at Singapore. I can find the standard plastic ones at the local market near my home but not the heart shaped ones. You have anyone living at Melbourne to buy these for you. Otherwise, please let me know and I can arrange something for you :D
Cheers!
Zoe
Couleurs et saveurs! Just perfect!
ReplyDeletelooks a wonderful mouthwatering assortment....delicious!
ReplyDeletegreat work for the comparisons!this will be very helpful to many incl me :D
ReplyDeleteWhoa! You are so hardworking in making and comparing the recipes. All 3 has its own texture. I like my pineapple tarts the Nyonya way, which is 'biscuity' close to a 'tart' like texture to the pastry. I don't really fancy the 'melt in the mouth' or very buttery texture when it comes to this cookie. I can tell you that I'm very picky with the types of pineapple tarts. From the looks of it, you had fun doing it and enjoyed doing it. I don't mind sampling some of yours and tell you which one I like most.. lol
ReplyDeleteI'm thinking too of baking some Nyonya ones based on some of Nyonya cookbooks... There are so many recipes to explore and yet so little time :D Please let me know if you have found any interesting recipes.
DeleteCheers!
Zoe
I love these heart shape pineapple tarts, look lovely and delicious.
ReplyDeleteWishing you and your family have a wonderful Chinese New Year!
Zoe I adore your pinapple tarts:))
ReplyDeleteZoe thanks for sharing the recipe wjti pineapple. I didn't know that there are so many tasty bakings can be done with the fruit.
ReplyDeleteGee...thanks for helping with the link Zoe, I so totally forgot to do it lol!
ReplyDeleteDone, thanks Zoe!
ReplyDeleteHello Zoe, thank you very much for extending this event and thanks for adding my posts too :)
ReplyDeleteHi Zoe,
ReplyDeleteThanks for inviting me to submit for this event. I have already linked my pineapple post to your blog. I am not sure if this is what I should do next but here is the link to my post : http://www.renryl.blogspot.sg/2013/02/pineapple-tarts-rolled-and-open-faced.html
Hi Zoe,
ReplyDeleteThanks for inviting me to submit for this event. I have already linked my pineapple post to your blog : ) cheers !
http://www.leesa2013.blogspot.sg/2013/01/golden-pineapple-balls.html
Hi Zoe,
ReplyDeleteThanks for the info. You have done all the hard work for us. I like your blog very much. Keep on the good work.
Hi you mentioned on an earlier comment that you can buy the tart moulds in Melbourne, I live in Adelaide. Any ideas about where to buy one here or can I get one sent from Melbourne somehow? Thank you!
ReplyDeleteHi Marianne,
DeleteBelieve or not, I've asked the shop that sells the mould why is she not doing an online business for her products and she said that she did before but it became a hassle when she has to spend all the time and effort to send small products and she earns less than a dollar for doing this and so she stopped. I guess you have to make a trip to Melbourne (Preston Market) if you really want to buy these.
Otherwise, have you try ebay?
Zoe
Hello! I'm wondering which stall in preston market did you buy the pineapple tart mould from? I'm currently staying in melbourne and would like to buy one of these moulds. Thanks in advance! Cheers!
ReplyDeleteHi, You can buy the mould from a baking supply shop in the Preston Market owned by a Malaysian couple. It is very obvious and you can't miss it :)
DeleteZoe