Monday, March 9, 2015

Ultra Soft and Feather-light Banana Chiffon Cake

"Mum, can you pleaseee... bake this cake again?" pleaded my son whenever he ate the last slice of this banana chiffon cake.

Again? Yes that I have baked this banana chiffon cake from Christine's recipe twice and yet my son can't have enough of it!!!

Twice? For my first bake, I have baked the cake without the addition of cream of tartar and yielded an ultra soft and feather-light but rather short cake. Why am I omitting the cream of tartar? ... because I believe that the cream of tartar often acts as a stabilizer of meringue which can potentially cause the cake to more stable and rigid with less softer texture. However, I have realised that the addition of cream of tartar can play quite an essential role in this recipe. Despite that I have followed the recipe entirely by using a 20cm tube pan, just lacking the cream of tartar simply can't beef up the volume of my first cake.

To avoid having a short cake, I have baked the cake with the addition of cream of tartar and used a tall 17cm tube for my second cake. Although it works beautifully, the cake is less feathery light because of its stable structure. I have also noticed that the addition of 1/2 tsp cream of tartar is quite a high amount for chiffon cake in this size and has given the cake a hint of sourish aftertaste.

In regardless whether the cake is short or not, sourish or not, my son is still a sucker for its feathery light texture and banana-y taste.


Mum, can you pleaseee... bake this cake again? For my son, I might have to bake this cake again... Maybe with cream of tartar or not??? I can't really decide.

Update on 18 Oct 2016: Please go to this post for my BEST ultra soft banana chiffon cake recipe.

banana chiffon cake
Very soft and feather-light Banana Chiffon Cake
Without cream of tartar, this is what I get...
A short but super ultra soft chiffon cake!
I have used two very ripe banana and oil to bake my cakes
Typically, this is the yellow part of the chiffon cake batter.
Sift in the dry ingredients and whisk gently until combined.
Typically again.. This is the white part of the chiffon cake batter.
Then, mix the yellow and white together and bake!
To minimize shrinkage, I have inverted the cake immediately and allow it to cool...
... but the cake is still so short like this!!!
Obviously, this recipe needs the addition of cream of tartar!
And, I have baked this second chiffon cake with cream of tartar.
... and yielded this tall and stable cake.
Wow!!! This is the soft and feathery light chiffon texture that I'm talking about.
... but the cake without the cream of tartar is ultimately the softest!

To add or not to add? I have been caught in this dilemma of adding cream of tartar in this recipe like a million of times!!!

If I don't add the cream of tartar, the cake will be extremely soft but structurally, it will not be stable. To the extent that it is actually quite challenging to cut the cake without squashing it.

If I choose to add the cream of tartar, I will get a nice looking stable chiffon cake but slightly less softer with a hint of sourish aftertaste.

To add or not to add? What do you think?

Here's the recipe that is mostly adapted from Christine's recipe

Update on 18 Oct 2016: Please go to this post for my BEST ultra soft banana chiffon cake recipe.

Makes one 8-inch (20 cm) short or 6.7-inch (17cm) tall round tube cake 
As the cake is very feathery light and fragile, it is highly recommended to use cake pan with removable base.

Ingredients A:
2 ripe large bananas, peeled, about 240g without the skins

3 egg yolks (45g)
35g vegetable oil
45g milk at room temperature
80g cake flour
1/8 tsp salt

Ingredients B:
4 egg whites (160g)
50g caster sugar
1/2 tsp cream of tartar*

*If you don't add the cream of tartar, your cake will be extremely soft but structurally, it will not be stable. If you add the cream of tartar, your cake will be stable and easier to handle but less softer with a hint of sourish aftertaste.

Preheat oven to 170°C or 330ºF or 150°C fan forced. 

For ingredients A:
Use a small or handheld food processor to process the bananas into smooth purée. Set aside.

Using a hand whisk, combine egg yolks, oil, milk and mashed bananas in a large mixing bowl until well combined. Sift in cake flour and salt and whisk gently until the batter is smooth and combined.

For ingredients B:
Use an electric mixer with a whisk attachment, beat egg whites at medium speed for about 2-3 mins until bubbles form. While beating, add cream of tartar*. Increase the whisking speed to high and add the caster sugar gradually in 3-4 batches. Continue to beat until stiff peaks form.

Fold in the egg whites mixture into the egg yolk mixture by batches. Add one third of egg whites at a time to incorporate the egg whites into egg yolk mixture. Mix the batter gently. Add the another one third of the egg whites into the egg yolk mixture. Keep mixing gently. Mix in the rest when the second third of the egg whites and the egg yolk mixture are well combined.

Pour the batter into an un-greased cake pan and bake for 55 to 60 mins. Remove from oven and invert the cake immediately to cool on a wire rack. Allow it to cool completely before removing it from the cake pan. The cake can be very fragile and easily squashed and so it is better to slice with a serrated knife. Serve and I'm sure that you will be in love with this super ultra light banana cake!

Happy Baking
Please support me and like me at Facebook...

21 comments:

  1. Your cake looks really relaly soft and light, yummeehhh !! I've eaten pandan chiffon and orange chiffon, but never heard of banana chiffon.. You are so clever, using "heavy" stuffs (bananas) to make the cake into a light fluffy one (coz I always feel bananas will sink the cake down) !! Give me the whole cake, no problem for me one !!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nawww!!! I just love all things about banana :D

    ReplyDelete
  3. Quite a conundrum, Zoe. I don't know what to tell you. I think it's adorable that son is requesting the cake again. does he prefer the short version or the tall version, lol...

    I remember doing a research post on Harry Baker, the man who is said to have "invented" Chiffon Cake. From what I can tell, the original recipe did have 1/2 tsp. of cream of tartar for a large cake with 7 or 8 egg whites and 1/4 tsp. for a smaller cake made with about 4 egg whites. The original recipe also has baking powder as an ingredient in the A list. (3tsp. for large cake; 1 and 1/2 for a smaller cake)

    Which ever way you bake it, Zoe, I'll LOVE it and I know for surely your son will LOVE it too!!! Thanks for sharing, Zoe...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Louise,

      I thought so... This recipe with just 4 egg white should use 1/4 tsp cream of tartar instead of 1/2 tsp. For me, I prefer the one with no cream of tartar which is softer but uglier :p My son said that he don't mind either short or tall version as both are fluffy and soft enough to him :D

      Zoe

      Delete
  4. with cream of tartar or not, i love this with a cuppa anytime... one of the most classic bakes and yours look really yummy!!

    ReplyDelete
  5. I prefer not adding it. I just don't like too much of chemical stuff in my cake. unless I bake it for an event, people always look for nice presentation rather than the test like we do right? haha.

    ReplyDelete
  6. That looks amazing soft! Wow...

    ReplyDelete
  7. Zoe, can I have a piece of your yummy Banana Chiffon Cake to go with my piping hot coffee, pleaseeee?

    ReplyDelete
  8. Yen, I must bake this banana chiffon cake! Your's looks so soft and spongy. No wonder your son can't get enough!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Phong Hong,

      I think you have mistaken me as Yen... LOL!

      Delete
    2. Opsie! Apologies, Zoe! I knew I was in your blog but my fingers were thinking of Yen LOL! I'm getting senile liao :D

      Delete
  9. Zoe, banana cake is so delicious and yours looks so soft!

    ReplyDelete
  10. Zoe come sempre sei bravissima

    ReplyDelete
  11. Hi Zoe, both cakes are so super soft and feathery light chiffon texture to me ... Yummy-licious!

    ReplyDelete
  12. I probably would skip the cream of tartar as sometimes its unavailable over here ...

    ReplyDelete
  13. This looks so feather light..... and yummy banana chiffon cake.... :)

    ReplyDelete
  14. Haha Phong Hong, I am so "touched" that I am in your "fingers"... hahahaha.

    Anyway Zoe, I can tell that your cake is very soft and fluffy. Looks really good!

    ReplyDelete
  15. Thank you for the experiments! I probably won't put cream of tartar in just because of slightly funny after taste. The cake with cream of tartar is better looking though. Sounds so great!

    ReplyDelete
  16. Oh wowie! Any banana lover's dream! I love all types of banana products! Cake, muffins, bread, pastry, pie! Everything and this looks fabulous! That's so sweet that your son was asking for it again and again, that's a sign of a favorite food! That cream of tar tar sure made a HUGE difference in that rise!

    ReplyDelete
  17. I think either of these banana cakes looks great! I think I'd agree with your son that they're both good. :)

    ReplyDelete